Rethinking Rescue

Starred review from June 3, 2024
In this eye-opening account, journalist Mithers (Mighty Be Our Powers) profiles L.A.-based animal welfare advocate Lori Weise, presenting her activism since the 1990s in evocative juxtaposition with an examination of how classist undertones have since emerged in the very movement Weise spearheaded. Now largely led by wealthy donor-activists, today’s rescue movement seeks to remove animals from “undeserving” homes, according to Mithers’s well-researched history, which spotlights other prominent figures like Hollywood philanthropist Gillian Lange, whose organization instituted the first background checks for pet adopters. But when Weise first became active in the movement, “rescue” meant saving animals from euthanasia in shelters—not “unsafe” homes—and keeping them united with their owners, most of whom had fallen on hard times. Indeed, Weise first began promoting “no kill” policies because of her work with homeless people. As an employee at a factory on L.A.’s Skid Row, she got to know the area’s homeless population, and she was drawn into the no-kill battle as a means of bolstering the emotional health of those living on the street, whose relationships with animals strengthened their spirit. Mithers applauds Weise’s work but doesn’t cut corners; she unflinchingly depicts the harrowing conditions pets face in homeless encampments. The result is a provocative challenge to contemporary mores regarding animal welfare.

December 6, 2024

Mithers (coauthor of Mighty Be Our Powers: How Sisterhood, Prayer, and Sex Changed a Nation at War) delves into the challenges of poverty and being unhoused as she questions who truly deserves the love of a pet. Narrator Christina Delaine varies her tone with compassion and empathy throughout the presentation and reading. Centered on Lori Weise, known in Los Angeles's underserved communities as the Dog Lady, the audiobook chronicles her long commitment to people in poverty and the animals they share. Mithers emphasizes the critical link between human and animal suffering, thereby presenting Weise's innovative approach as a model for a compassionate narrative for rescue. The author also sheds light on biases within the animal-welfare movement, which frequently prioritizes placing pets in higher-income homes while neglecting low-income pet owners. Weise's efforts to challenge this status quo demonstrate that support for marginalized pet owners can significantly reduce shelter intake rates. Mithers's exploration of Weise's work reveals the broader implications of social justice, highlighting how systemic inequality impacts both people and their pets. VERDICT A story of hope and empathy, this audiobook is for all readers, especially animal lovers.--Susan McClellan

Copyright 2024 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.